Macclesfield
Macclesfield
2 vs 2

FA Cup · Matchday

2026-10-03 14:00:00 · 22:00

Scarborough Athletic
Scarborough Athletic

AI Predicted: 1-0|Actual: 2-2

WinnerScoreO/U 2.5BTTS

AI Prediction

Macclesfield
MAC
1 - 0
Scarborough Athletic
SCA
53%
Confidence
Low Confidence
52.0%Home
24.0%Draw
24.0%Away
53.8%Home
23.8%Draw
22.3%Away
Macclesfield enter this FA Cup tie as narrow favorites, boosted by Scarborough Athletic being dealt a significant blow with T. Wilson ruled out through Red Card Suspension. That enforced absence disrupts Scarborough's structure and could leave them vulnerable to Macclesfield's attacking transitions in a tight, low-scoring contest. AI pick: Macclesfield Win

Top AI Picks

AI-generated recommendations
Two outcomes coveredHome or Draw
76% probability
Over or Under 2.5 goalsUnder 2.5
56% chance of 0-2 goals
Will both teams find the net?No
62% one side shut out
Handicap advantage pick—No data available
Most likely to score—No data available

Goal Probability

Macclesfield Scarborough Athletic
13%
44%
0
46%
56%
1
41%
0%
2
0%
0%
3+

Odds Comparison

52%
54%
-1.8%
24%
24%
+0.2%
24%
22%
+1.7%
PredictNext AI Market Avg
AI & Market Agree: Home Win

Polymarket Odds

Loading prediction market data...

Trading Strategy

Loading market depth data...

Match Report

FA Cup First Round: Macclesfield 2–2 Scarborough Athletic

A dramatic late comeback from Macclesfield denied Scarborough Athletic what would have been a well-earned FA Cup victory, as Paul Dawson's brace in the final ten minutes rescued a share of the spoils at the Moss Rose on Saturday afternoon.

Match Analysis

Macclesfield dominated proceedings for large stretches of this contest, controlling 58% of possession and generating 13 shots in total — five of which were on target — compared to Scarborough's six shots overall. John Rooney's side also won six corners to Scarborough's two and recorded 84 dangerous attacks against Jonathan Greening's visitors' 55. By almost every statistical measure, Macclesfield were the more threatening side across the ninety minutes.

Yet it was Scarborough Athletic who struck with deadly efficiency just before the interval. Mo Fadera opened the scoring in the 41st minute, and within two minutes the visitors had doubled their advantage, Luke Hall adding a second on 43 minutes. That two-goal burst in the dying moments of the first half was a moment of clinical opportunism that belied Scarborough's relative passivity in the stats column, and it left Macclesfield with a mountain to climb after the break.

For much of the second half, Rooney's side pushed to overturn the deficit but appeared to be running out of time and ideas against a resolute Scarborough backline. Then, in the 81st minute, Paul Dawson pulled one back to set up a frantic closing spell. With the clock ticking down and the tie seemingly heading to a Scarborough victory, Dawson struck again in the 89th minute to complete an extraordinary personal comeback and draw Macclesfield level. The turnaround was a testament to Macclesfield's persistence, even if their inability to convert their statistical dominance throughout the game had left them needing a late miracle.

Scarborough had just three shots on target across the ninety minutes, but their compact performance and those two precise strikes before half-time nearly proved sufficient. Greening's side will reflect on a point — or potentially more — that slipped through their fingers in the final stages.

Prediction Review

Our pre-match analysis had forecasted a narrow Macclesfield home win at 1–0, assigning a 52% probability to a home victory and placing the draw at just 24%. That prediction proved incorrect, with the match ending in a 2–2 draw. To be fair, the forecast carried a low confidence rating of 53/100, reflecting the genuine uncertainty surrounding this tie. Macclesfield's statistical dominance throughout the match did support the notion that they were the stronger side, but Scarborough's clinical finishing before half-time underlined how unpredictable FA Cup football can be. The draw outcome fell in line with what our model acknowledged as a credible alternative scenario.

Key Takeaways

  • Paul Dawson's late double was the defining moment of this tie, turning what looked like a Scarborough victory into a share of the spoils.
  • Macclesfield's statistical superiority — in possession, shots, and dangerous attacks — did not translate into goals until the very late stages, highlighting the importance of defensive organisation at this level.
  • Scarborough's effectiveness in front of goal with minimal opportunities demonstrates why non-league cup ties often defy conventional analysis.
  • Both clubs will now prepare for a replay, with the tie finely balanced heading into the next stage.

Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic — Frequently Asked Questions

Who will win Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic?

PredictNext's AI model favours Macclesfield with a 52% win probability — Macclesfield 52%, draw 24%, Scarborough Athletic 24%.

What is the predicted score for Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic?

The AI forecasts a 1-0 scoreline for Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic, generated with 53% model confidence.

Will Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic have over 2.5 goals?

The model gives 44% for over 2.5 goals and 56% for under 2.5 goals in Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic.

How accurate was the Macclesfield vs Scarborough Athletic prediction?

PredictNext's AI predicted 1-0; the match finished 2-2. The winner call was incorrect.

More FA Cup AI Predictions